Quote
bahamut
Today Hulu just slammed HTML5 as not being ready for the purposes. We'll see how they do as far as iPad apps go, the context of that is clear.
The thing is that the user experience of Apple's iBooks is so low (inferior to kindle) that we might as well go with LCD books and magazines. The demos of Wired via Flash are in an entirely different league than iBooks.
I am curious to see what mind altering things a "user experience designer" can do in Flash that are not possible to implement in either the iPhone OS SDK or HTML5. I do believe that currently it may be more difficult to do some things in the non-Flash world, but to say it CAN NOT be done strikes me as false in the extreme. In fact I suspect that any one that says such a thing is really revealing their lack of talent. I am reminded of an IBM from about a decade ago where a "boss" is trying to build an "ecommerce site" and the dunderheaded techies that he has assigned to the task can't do much more than make a "flaming logo" --
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LkQrtCIFA4
Now don't get me wrong, it may very well be that in this the first iteration of Apple's iPad the tooling to build really slick interactive immersive multi-media-esque applications that expand upon the metaphor of a "periodical" in every way is slightly lacking, yet to think that because of that lack of the answer is to go with a stack of technologies who roots lie in a world of slide shows and amateur animation strikes me as bizarre. Apple has EVERYTHING TO LOSE if they do not produce tools of stunning quality, power and ease of use. Does no one believe that their acquistions over the last decade or more have been HIGHLY STRATEGIC, AMAZINGLY SYNERGINISTIC, and RUTHLESSLY PROTECTIVE of their abilities to grow?
Admittedly. maybe I am mistaken, and no one really spends money on the products that Apple does not tout as publicly as say "iTunes", but it sure seem this is important stuff to people doing some pretty specialized stuff:
http://discussions.apple.com/forum.jspa?forumID=1202
http://discussions.apple.com/forum.jspa?forumID=1201
http://discussions.apple.com/forum.jspa?forumID=656