Quote
James DeBenedetti
I haven't read it yet (I'm still re-reading book 3 for the first time since it came out, in preparation for book 4, which I never got around to), but
Brad DeLong has.
So, based on that metric of performance the Unabomber's manifesto has more literary worth than one of Shakespeare's sonnets?
< rant >
I'm not criticising Martin on his words-per-year output, I greatly prefer quality over quantity (J K Rowling, I'm looking at you). Martin at his best creates an evocative landscape almost as detailed and complex as Tolkien. At his worst he can fill several pages talking about nothing but heraldry, medieval food/drink/customs without progressing the story at all. I know he's a huge fan of that era and has researched hundreds of larges tomes on every aspect of it - and while it adds authenticity to the story there is too much of a good thing. It's like an undergrad uni student who's done all this *great* research and just
has to fit it in somewhere and thus triples their essay word limit.
The first two books have told a lot more story than the last three. More storytelling, less waffle about roasted capons (which is a knackered rooster apparently), boiled leather jerkins and patterned doublets (apparently a double-lined vest) and other window dressing...
< / rant >
That tangent aside I actually wasn't criticising Martin in the previous post (but boy I had a good whinge here to make up for it, hey?), just making the observation that he appears to be exhausted by writing the whole series.
Let's hope I'm wrong.