tliet:
While you say that mom or dad COULD sell their place and move to a rental I'm dealing with several relatives that, mostly for emotional/independence issues won't -- frankly as I get older I can see their point. It is hard enough to lose a spouse or have to deal with disease and to put the extra burden of making changes to how/where you live is almost too much. My sister is a nurse with hospice experience and says that among most people they won't shift until well after a crisis forces them to do so...
rino:
I really think that "success" is all about getting people to a point where they don't just "survive" but they have a "need to thrive". There are many many paths toward that end, as mokers highlights immigrants come packed with a lot of that "need", for others a stint in the service helps to focus things, for others (maybe Bill's kids) it is parental guidance/ass whooping.
One thing that depressed me a lot when I was teaching high school was just how miserable the average is -- from lack of intelligence to lack of training to lack of curiosity American teachers generally suck. Of course there are plenty of exceptions, but too often the best teachers end up working with kids that need them least -- America really ought to realize that competition is so ingrained in how we get into colleges, how we get jobs, how most people advance in their careers, how we decide where and how to live that it is beyond silly to let poor/mediocre coaches and gym teachers make the same as excellent teachers of mathematics, science, English -- the foundations of productiveness. WSJ took a look at Finland, well known as heavy very good academic performers. What they found was not surprising: very good teachers and students with a healthy sense of responsibility. No magic, but hard to reproduce too.
http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB120425355065601997-7Bp8YFw7Yy1n9bdKtVyP7KBAcJA_20080330.html (free now that Bloomberg is knocking down most of the "walled garden"...)
I agree that Americans that make up the "non achieving" constitute a serious problem, though having seen first hand that too often literal brothers and sisters that were raised about identically as can be end up as different as 'goofus & gallant ' -- one having not just the drive to do well, but also doing good, while the other wallows in immature self-indulgence if not outright criminality. These are not differences of just "Head Start" but something more troubling; how much mental health assistance is given to kids/young adults that are violent? I fear that America's prison population will always be far larger than other countries -- with our extreme smörgåsbord of lifestyles and over acceptance of what few other societies would tolerate it is too easy for the truly sick to just blend in until they finally up before an angry frustrated court for too many heinous crimes any are incarcerated for the rest of the life.
http://www.suntimes.com/news/24-7/821806,CST-NWS-stab02.article